Introduction
In the ever-evolving landscape of project management, one name has consistently echoed through the halls of tech companies and startups alike: JIRA. Atlassian's flagship has long been the beacon for tracking development milestones and navigating the complexities of software projects. However, as the digital panorama shifts, a growing number of teams are seeking horizons beyond the familiar confines of JIRA.
Why the quest for alternatives, one might wonder? The answer lies not in the shortcomings of JIRA but in the diverse aspirations of organizations. The allure of autonomy, the promise of privacy, and the drive for cost-efficiency spur the search for solutions that offer the same robust functionality but on their own terms.
Enter the realm of open-source and self-hosted systems—a universe where the source code whispers the sweet language of freedom and customization. Here, in the rich soil of community-driven innovation, alternatives to JIRA are taking root, promising a new era of project management that aligns with the unique needs and values of modern teams.
As we set the stage to unveil these alternatives, we recognize the pivotal role JIRA has played in shaping project management. Yet, we also acknowledge the dynamic nature of the industry and the growing appetite for open-source, self-hosted platforms that empower businesses to own their tools as much as they own their outcomes.
Join us on this exploratory journey as we delve into the best open-source JIRA alternatives that are reshaping the project management landscape, offering the freedom to self-host and the power to personalize.
Benefits of Open-Source PM Tools
In the digital age, the open-source movement represents more than just a way to access and modify software code. It is a testament to collaboration, innovation, and freedom in software development. As businesses and developers increasingly turn their gaze towards open-source solutions, the reasons behind this shift become as clear as daylight.
Empowering Businesses with Flexibility and Cost Efficiency
For businesses, the allure of open-source software lies in its unparalleled flexibility and cost efficiency. Gone are the days of exorbitant licensing fees and the shackles of vendor lock-in. Open source offers an economical alternative that puts control back in the hands of those who use the software.
Fostering Innovation Through Collaboration
The open-source ethos encourages a level of collaboration that proprietary models can scarcely dream of. Developers from around the globe contribute to a shared goal, pooling their expertise to create more robust, secure, and innovative solutions.
Building Community and Involvement
Beyond the code, open-source software builds communities. It provides a platform for developers to learn from one another, share knowledge, and grow together. These communities become a source of support and inspiration.
In essence, the appeal of open-source software transcends the practical benefits of cost savings and customization. It embodies a philosophy of openness, collaboration, and mutual growth that is reshaping the landscape of software development and project management.
Why Self-Hosted Project Management Tools?
In the quest for the ideal project management solution, the choice between cloud-based and self-hosted platforms presents a pivotal decision for businesses. Embracing a self-hosted model offers a trifecta of control, security, and customization that can significantly empower a company.
Unparalleled Control Over Your Data
One of the most compelling reasons to opt for a self-hosted project management tool is the unparalleled control it offers over your data. In an era where data is as valuable as currency, having direct oversight over where and how your data is stored is crucial.
Enhanced Security: Your Fortress, Your Rules
Security concerns are at the forefront of the digital workspace. Self-hosted solutions offer a level of security customization that cloud services can't match. By hosting your project management tool on-premises or with a chosen provider, you can implement security protocols that meet or exceed your organization's standards.
Tailored Customization: Crafting Your Ideal Tool
Every organization has unique needs, workflows, and processes. Self-hosted project management tools provide the flexibility to customize features, interfaces, and integrations to fit your specific requirements.
Considerations for Choosing a Self-Hosted Platform
While the benefits are clear, choosing a self-hosted project management tool requires careful consideration. Infrastructure, IT support, and maintenance capabilities are crucial factors to evaluate.
How to Choose the Best JIRA Alternative: Guide to Find Open-Source, Self-Hosted PM Solutions
In the vast sea of project management tools, finding the right JIRA alternative can feel like navigating uncharted waters. The decision to switch hinges on a careful evaluation of potential candidates, ensuring they not only match but surpass the functionalities you've come to rely on.
Core Criteria for Selection
1. Feature Parity with Flexibility
Key Consideration: Does the alternative offer the core features you rely on in JIRA, such as issue tracking, agile boards, and reporting capabilities? Furthermore, assess the flexibility of these features to adapt to your team's evolving needs.
2. User Experience and Accessibility
Key Consideration: An intuitive user interface and ease of use are paramount. The best tool is one that your team can seamlessly adopt, reducing the learning curve and increasing productivity.
3. Integration Ecosystem
Key Consideration: Your project management tool doesn't exist in isolation. Evaluate the available integrations with other tools and services your team uses, such as version control systems, CI/CD pipelines, and communication platforms.
4. Cost-Effectiveness
Key Consideration: Beyond the upfront cost, consider the total cost of ownership, including setup, customization, and potential scalability needs. Open-source, self-hosted options often offer significant savings in the long run.
5. Data Management and Security
Key Consideration: Assess the data management capabilities and security features. This is particularly crucial for self-hosted solutions, where you're responsible for your data's safety and compliance.
The Role of Community and Development
An active and engaged community, coupled with ongoing development, is the backbone of any successful open-source project. A vibrant community offers a wealth of resources, from troubleshooting guides and forums to third-party plugins and integrations.
1. Redmine: The Veteran Project Manager
In the realm of open-source project management tools, Redmine stands out as a seasoned veteran. Since its inception, it has provided teams across the globe with a reliable, versatile platform for managing a wide array of projects.
What is Redmine?
Redmine, written in Ruby on Rails, is a free and open-source project management application that champions flexibility and simplicity. It caters to various types of projects, offering support for multiple project management strategies including Agile methodologies.
Key Features and Benefits
- Project Management: Redmine supports multiple projects, allowing teams to track and manage several initiatives under one umbrella.
- Flexible Issue Tracking System: At the heart of Redmine is its issue tracking system, which can be tailored to fit the workflow of any team.
- Gantt Charts and Calendar: Visual tools like Gantt charts and calendars provide a graphical representation of project timelines and deadlines.
- Role-based Access Control: With its comprehensive access control system, Redmine ensures that sensitive information is accessible only to authorized personnel.
- Extensible with Plugins: The functionality of Redmine can be extended through a wide array of plugins.
- Multilingual Support: Redmine breaks language barriers by offering multilingual support.
Space for setup guide image
Community Ecosystem
The Redmine community is a testament to the tool's impact and utility. It's composed of developers, project managers, and users who contribute to the software's development, offer plugins, and support new users.
2. Wekan: Kanban for the Minimalist
In the search for simplicity and efficiency in project management, Wekan emerges as a shining beacon for teams embracing the Kanban methodology. This open-source tool strips away the complexity, offering a straightforward, visually intuitive platform for managing workflows.
Wekan's Approach to Kanban-Style Project Management
Wekan is built on the foundational principles of Kanban: visualize your work, limit work in progress, and enhance flow. It translates these principles into a digital board where tasks are represented as cards that move across columns.
Simplicity and User Interface
Wekan's user interface is a testament to the power of minimalism. With an uncluttered design, it focuses on what's essential — the boards, lists, and cards. This simplicity doesn't come at the expense of functionality.
Space for Wekan interface image
Self-Hosting Wekan and Its Community
Opting for Wekan doesn't mean sacrificing control or security. The platform offers a self-hosted solution that gives teams full control over their data and the flexibility to configure the tool to their specific needs.
3. Plane: Your Open-Source Project Management Tool
In the evolving world of project management, finding a tool that simplifies rather than complicates can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Enter Plane: a modern, open-source platform designed to cut through the clutter, bringing simplicity and clarity to project management and issue tracking.
Why Choose Plane?
- Embrace Open Source: Plane offers the best of both worlds: the flexibility and security of open-source software combined with the ease of a user-friendly interface.
- See it Your Way: Plane champions versatility in project visualization. Whether you're a fan of list views, Kanban boards, calendars, or Gantt charts, Plane allows you to customize your project's workflow visualization.
- Adaptable Approach: With Plane, your project management style is never boxed in. Agile, Waterfall, or a hybrid approach? Plane adapts to your methodology.
- Unleash Customization: Make Plane your own by extending its functionality through integrations, custom fields, and tailored workflows.
Plane's Key Features
- Issue Tracking: Streamline the creation, management, and tracking of issues with Plane's intuitive interface.
- Sprint Planning: Tackle large projects with ease by breaking them down into sprints using Plane's "Cycles" feature.
- Product Roadmaps: Keep your team aligned with clear, visually engaging product roadmaps.
- Collaboration Made Easy: Plane is designed to foster team collaboration with real-time updates, in-issue discussions, and mentions.
Space for Plane dashboard image
4. GitLab: More Than Version Control
In the world of software development and project management, GitLab has emerged as a formidable force, transcending its origins as a version control repository to become a comprehensive DevOps platform.
GitLab's Integrated Approach to Project Management
GitLab stands out by offering an all-in-one platform for software development, from planning and coding to testing, deploying, and monitoring. This integration reduces the need for multiple tools, making the management of software projects more efficient and cohesive.
How it Compares with JIRA's Features
- Issue Tracking and Project Management: Like JIRA, GitLab offers robust issue-tracking capabilities, but it integrates these features directly with its version control system.
- Agile and Scrum Boards: GitLab supports agile project management methodologies through its issue boards.
- CI/CD Pipelines: A standout feature of GitLab is its built-in CI/CD pipelines, which automate the stages of software delivery from build to deployment.
- Merge Requests for Code Review: GitLab's merge requests are a powerful tool for code review and collaboration.
Space for GitLab interface image
Implementation and Support
GitLab offers a self-hosted option as well as a cloud-hosted solution, providing flexibility depending on your organization's needs. Its comprehensive documentation and active community forums aid in the implementation process.
5. Taiga.io: Agile, Open, and User-Friendly
In the landscape of agile project management tools, Taiga.io shines as a beacon for teams committed to the agile and scrum methodologies. This open-source platform is designed with a keen focus on user experience, making agile project management accessible, intuitive, and efficient.
Focus on Agile Development with Taiga.io
Taiga.io is built from the ground up to support agile development processes, offering features that facilitate sprint planning, backlog grooming, and retrospectives with ease. Its native support for both Scrum and Kanban methodologies means teams can choose the framework that best suits their project's needs.
Enhancing User Experience and Workflow Management
- Intuitive Interface: Taiga.io stands out for its clean and intuitive user interface, designed to minimize learning curves and maximize productivity.
- Customizable Workflows: Understanding that no two projects are the same, Taiga.io offers customizable workflows that allow teams to define their own stages and transitions.
- Real-time Collaboration: Collaboration is key in agile development, and Taiga.io facilitates this by offering features like real-time updates, comments, and mentions.
Space for Taiga.io interface image
Deployment and Customization Options
Being open-source, Taiga.io offers the ultimate flexibility in deployment options. Teams can choose to use the cloud-hosted version for convenience or self-host Taiga.io on their own servers for complete control over their data and environment.
6. OpenProject: Comprehensive Project Management Suite
OpenProject emerges as a formidable ally in the realm of project management, offering a comprehensive suite that caters to the multifaceted demands of modern projects. This open-source platform combines a wealth of features with the flexibility and control that today's teams crave.
A Feature-Rich Tool Tailored for Efficiency
OpenProject is designed with the understanding that effective project management hinges on the ability to view, organize, and adjust every facet of a project in real-time.
- Gantt Charts for Visual Planning: OpenProject elevates project planning through its robust Gantt chart feature, allowing project managers and teams to visualize project timelines and dependencies at a glance.
- Task Management and Workflow Customization: At its core, OpenProject facilitates detailed task management, with features that allow for the creation, assignment, and tracking of tasks.
- Integrated Time Tracking: Understanding the importance of time as a resource, OpenProject incorporates time tracking directly within tasks and projects.
Space for OpenProject Gantt chart image
Deployment and Customization
The open-source nature of OpenProject presents users with unparalleled flexibility in terms of deployment and customization. OpenProject offers both a cloud-based solution and a self-hosted option.
7. Kanboard: Embracing Simplicity with Kanban
In a world where project management tools can often become as complex as the projects they aim to manage, Kanboard stands apart with its minimalistic approach. Rooted in the principles of Kanban, Kanboard is designed to streamline project workflows, enhancing productivity and focus through simplicity.
The Essence of Kanboard's Design
Kanboard's interface is intentionally sparse, focusing on the core components of Kanban: boards, lists, and cards. This design choice isn't merely aesthetic; it's a deliberate effort to reduce cognitive load and help teams concentrate on what truly matters—their work.
Kanban in its Purest Form
Kanboard embodies the key tenets of Kanban, including visualizing work, limiting work in progress, and optimizing the flow of tasks. Users can create customizable boards that reflect their project's stages, from conception to completion.
Space for Kanboard interface image
Self-Hosting and Extensibility
Kanboard's open-source framework provides the freedom to self-host your project management environment, giving you full control over your data and the security measures protecting it.
8. Gitea: The Lightweight Powerhouse for Code Hosting and Issue Tracking
In the ever-expanding universe of Git services, Gitea emerges as a standout choice for teams and individuals looking for a straightforward, efficient, and community-driven platform. Gitea's charm lies in its lightweight framework and ease of use, coupled with essential features that facilitate smooth project management and collaboration.
Gitea at a Glance: Simplifying Code Hosting
Gitea is designed to be a minimalist yet powerful Git service, focusing on speed and simplicity without sacrificing functionality. It is an open-source platform, meaning it's freely available for anyone to use, modify, and distribute.
Key Features: Beyond Just Code Hosting
- Basic Issue Tracking: Gitea includes an integrated issue tracker that allows teams to manage bugs and feature requests directly within the platform.
- Pull Requests and Code Review: Encouraging collaboration, Gitea supports pull requests with commenting and review functionalities.
- Customizable Dashboards: Users can tailor their dashboards to display pertinent information regarding their projects.
- Lightweight and Efficient: One of Gitea's most significant advantages is its lightweight architecture.
Space for Gitea interface image
The Community: Heart of Gitea
The backbone of Gitea is its vibrant and active community. Being open-source, Gitea benefits from the collective expertise and enthusiasm of developers worldwide who contribute to its development, offer support, and create plugins that extend its functionality.
9. Fossil: A Unique Blend of Version Control and Collaboration Tools
Fossil stands out in the landscape of version control systems by offering a suite of integrated features that go beyond simple code management. As a distributed version control system, Fossil provides robust mechanisms for tracking changes and collaborating on code, but what truly sets it apart is its comprehensive approach to project documentation, issue tracking, and web interface accessibility.
The Core of Fossil: Distributed Version Control
At its heart, Fossil offers all the advantages of a distributed version control system (DVCS), similar to Git. This means every clone of the repository is a full backup of the entire project history, ensuring data integrity and facilitating offline work.
Beyond Code: Integrated Project Management Features
- Bug Tracking: Fossil includes an integrated bug tracking system that allows teams to report, manage, and track issues directly within the same environment where their code lives.
- Wiki for Documentation: Understanding the importance of comprehensive project documentation, Fossil incorporates a built-in wiki.
- Web Interface: One of Fossil's standout features is its user-friendly web interface, which provides a visual gateway to repository content, issue tracking, and documentation.
Space for Fossil interface image
The Community and Ecosystem
While Fossil might not boast as large a community as some other version control systems, its user base is passionate and dedicated. Users often cite Fossil's integrated approach and simplicity as reasons for their loyalty.
10. Phabricator
Phabricator is not just another tool in the software development arsenal; it's a comprehensive suite designed to streamline the development process from conception to deployment. As an open-source collection of tools, Phabricator facilitates code review, repository hosting, project management, and more, all within a cohesive ecosystem.
Unified Development Environment
At its core, Phabricator is about bringing together the various aspects of software development into a unified environment. This integration reduces context switching and promotes a more efficient workflow, as developers can manage their tasks, review code, and track issues all in one place.
Key Components of Phabricator
- Differential: A powerful tool for code review that supports inline comments and enables teams to discuss changes before they're merged into the main codebase.
- Diffusion: A repository hosting solution that supports Git, Mercurial, and Subversion.
- Maniphest: The project management component, Maniphest, allows for task creation, assignment, and prioritization.
- Phriction: A wiki tool that facilitates the documentation of projects, processes, and guidelines.
Space for Phabricator interface image
Building a Collaborative Culture
Beyond its technical capabilities, Phabricator is designed with collaboration at its heart. Its tools encourage transparency in the development process, facilitate open discussions around code quality, and promote a shared understanding of project goals and progress.
Several Other Opensource PM Tools
While the previously mentioned tools provide robust solutions for project management, code hosting, and collaboration, the open-source community is rich with other notable alternatives. Each brings unique selling points to the table, catering to different needs and preferences.
Leantime
Leantime is designed with startups and small to medium-sized teams in mind, offering a lean project management system that integrates idea management, project planning, and time tracking. Its unique selling point is the seamless integration of lean principles with traditional project management.
Freedcamp
Freedcamp stands out for its versatility, offering a suite of project management tools that cater to a wide range of needs, from task management to issue tracking, and invoicing. Its adaptability makes it suitable for freelancers, small businesses, and large enterprises alike.
TaskBoard
TaskBoard offers a simple, Kanban-style approach to task management, emphasizing ease of use and minimal setup. Its self-hosted nature and open-source licensing make it an excellent option for teams looking for a straightforward, no-frills solution.
Odoo
Odoo is more than a project management tool; it's a full suite of business applications, including CRM, eCommerce, accounting, and inventory management. Its project management module is highly customizable and integrates seamlessly with other business processes.
Tuleap
Tuleap is an all-in-one open-source project management tool designed to support Agile, traditional, hybrid, and DevOps project management styles. It's particularly strong in supporting software development processes with integrated tools for version control, continuous integration, and document management.
Feature Comparison Across Leading JIRA Alternatives
When navigating the waters of project management tools, distinguishing between the myriad options available becomes crucial. Understanding the core functionalities that drive project success is the first step.
Essential Features in a Project Management Tool
- Issue and Task Tracking: The ability to efficiently monitor tasks and issues is fundamental.
- Agile and Scrum Boards: For teams following Agile methodologies, boards that support Scrum or Kanban workflows are essential.
- Custom Workflows: Flexibility in defining workflows allows teams to tailor the tool to their specific processes.
- Reporting and Analytics: Insightful reporting tools enable better decision-making through data-driven insights.
- Integration Ecosystem: A robust set of integrations with version control systems, CI/CD pipelines, and other tools is crucial.
- User Permissions and Security: Advanced user management and security features ensure that sensitive information is appropriately protected.
- Customizable Dashboards: Personalized dashboards offer at-a-glance insights into project metrics.
- Collaboration Features: In-built communication tools such as comments, chat, and file sharing foster team collaboration.
Comparative Analysis: JIRA Alternatives at a Glance
Feature | JIRA | Redmine | GitLab | Taiga.io | Wekan | OpenProject | Kanboard | Gitea | Fossil | Phabricator |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Issue & Task Tracking | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
Agile & Scrum Boards | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | 🔶 | ✅ |
Custom Workflows | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | 🔶 | ✅ |
Reporting & Analytics | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ | 🔶 | 🔶 | 🔶 | ✅ |
Integration Ecosystem | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ |
User Permissions | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
Customizable Dashboards | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | ✅ | 🔶 | 🔶 | 🔶 | ✅ |
Collaboration Features | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 🔶 | 🔶 | ✅ |
This table provides a snapshot of how each alternative compares with JIRA in terms of critical functionalities. While JIRA sets a high standard with comprehensive feature support, several open-source alternatives offer compelling capabilities that can meet — or even exceed — your project management needs.
How to Switching Project Management Tools
Switching project management tools, especially from a well-established platform like JIRA, can seem daunting. However, with a structured approach and careful planning, the transition can lead to significant improvements in team efficiency and project outcomes.
Assessing Your Current Needs
- Identify Pain Points: Start by understanding why you're considering a switch. Is it due to cost, functionality, usability, or something else?
- Define Must-have Features: Based on your current project management challenges, outline the features your team can't do without.
- Evaluate Team Size and Scalability: Consider the size of your team and project complexity.
Making the Case for Switching from JIRA
- Highlight the Benefits: Compile a list of benefits the new tool offers over JIRA, focusing on how it addresses the pain points identified.
- Address Concerns Proactively: Change can be met with resistance. Address potential concerns by showing how the new tool aligns with your team's workflow and project goals.
- Present a Comparison: A side-by-side comparison of JIRA and the proposed alternative can be compelling.
Migration Considerations
- Data Migration Plan: Develop a detailed plan for migrating data from JIRA to the new tool.
- Test the Migration Process: Before the full migration, conduct a test run to identify any issues or data losses.
- Maintain Data Integrity and Continuity: Ensure that all data is accurately transferred and that ongoing projects are not disrupted.
Training and Adaptation
- Training Sessions: Organize training sessions to familiarize your team with the new tool.
- Adaptation Period: Allow time for your team to adapt to the new system.
- Leverage Support Resources: Utilize the new tool's support resources, such as documentation, forums, and customer support.
Best Practices for Adapting to a New Project Management Workflow
- Start Small: Begin with a pilot project to allow your team to get comfortable with the new tool.
- Foster Open Communication: Encourage team members to share their experiences, challenges, and tips.
- Monitor Progress and Gather Feedback: Regularly review how the transition is going, and be open to making adjustments based on team feedback.
Embracing the Future: Choosing the Right Path Beyond JIRA
As we conclude our exploration of the vibrant landscape of open-source, self-hosted JIRA alternatives, it's clear that the world of project management tools is both diverse and rich with potential. From the seasoned reliability of Redmine to the minimalist efficiency of Kanboard, the comprehensive suite offered by OpenProject, and the integrated DevOps approach of GitLab, there's a solution tailored to every team's unique needs and workflows.
The Promise of Open Source and Self-Hosting
The journey towards adopting an open-source, self-hosted project management solution is not just about replacing a tool but about embracing a philosophy. This approach promises more than cost savings; it offers the freedom to tailor your project management environment precisely to your team's needs, the autonomy over your data and infrastructure, and the agility to adapt to changing project landscapes.
Navigating the Transition with Confidence
The transition to a new project management tool is a significant undertaking, requiring careful consideration, planning, and support. However, the rewards — in terms of enhanced efficiency, team alignment, and project success — are well worth the effort.
The Path Ahead
Choosing to explore open-source, self-hosted alternatives to JIRA is a testament to your team's commitment to finding the best tools for your work. As you consider your options, remember that the goal is not just to find a replacement for JIRA but to discover a solution that will grow with your team, foster collaboration, and drive project success.
The project management tools we've discussed are just the beginning. The open-source community is continually evolving, with new tools and features developed in response to the needs of teams like yours. By staying engaged with these communities, you can contribute to the ongoing improvement of these tools and help shape the future of project management.
In conclusion, the journey from JIRA to an open-source, self-hosted alternative is a journey towards more than just a new tool. It's a step into a future where your project management software aligns perfectly with your team's needs, values, and aspirations. Embrace the change, and take your projects to new heights.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main advantages of open-source project management tools over proprietary solutions?
Open-source tools offer cost savings, complete customization freedom, no vendor lock-in, enhanced security through transparency, and active community support. You also get full control over your data and can modify the software to meet specific organizational needs.
Is it difficult to migrate from JIRA to an open-source alternative?
Migration complexity depends on your current setup and chosen alternative. Most tools offer import utilities for JIRA data. The key is proper planning, data mapping, team training, and potentially running both systems in parallel during transition.
Which open-source JIRA alternative is best for small teams?
For small teams, Wekan, Kanboard, or Taiga.io are excellent choices due to their simplicity and ease of setup. They offer essential project management features without overwhelming complexity.
Can these open-source tools handle enterprise-scale deployments?
Yes, tools like GitLab, OpenProject, and Redmine are designed to scale for enterprise use. They support thousands of users, complex workflows, and can be deployed across multiple servers for high availability.
What technical expertise is required to self-host these tools?
Basic system administration skills are needed, including server management, database setup, and security configuration. However, many tools offer Docker containers and detailed documentation to simplify deployment.
Ready to Explore Open-Source Project Management?
Discover how open-source, self-hosted project management tools can transform your team's productivity. Our experts can help you choose, deploy, and optimize the perfect JIRA alternative for your organization.
Get Expert Consultation